Recently, Ji-Li has been experience success in her school, but she has been unwilling to embrace it because she is too afraid of being ridiculed for being part of a "black" family. She even tried to change her last name in hopes of getting away from the "landlord family that she hated".
Assignment 6: due Monday, March 23
1. How do you feel about Ji-Li's outburst at her mother, when she screamed that she hated her landlord family? Was she justified in saying that or was she being cruel?
2. Ji-Li was elected for the Propaganda Committee and joined even though she thought her class status would get in the way. When the news of the 'Half-City Jiangs' got in the papers she eventually was taken off of the Exhibition.
-was this fair to do to her?
-have you ever been asked to be in a group that you felt like you did not belong in? Whould you have joined such a group?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think she told her mother that just because she was angry, and she didnt know what other thing she should say.
ReplyDelete2. No this was not fair to her, her grandpa's problems should not affect her in any way. They asked her if she wanted to make a break from her family, I would say no because family is something you need to have.No I dont join groups that I don't think i belong in.
she was mad because her grand father was a landlord and noboby liked the landlords yes but i never wanted to be in a group
ReplyDelete1.she was being justifed because when you mad u say anything that come out of your head so what i think she try to show how she felt and it just came out that was good what she did cause it let people to in her family to know how she felt
ReplyDelete2.i think that was not far because what happeing to her is very great she having all the good grades and she been the good student but everything gets messupbecause of her class status
1)i think she said that because she was sick and tired of hearing people saying tht she is from a balck family
ReplyDelete2)it was not fare because she was not alive at the time and her grand pa died when her dad was 7 so she should not be afcted about this
1.i think that she should have never said that to her mom because it not the mothers fault that her grandfather is a landlord.so to mei think that ji-li was wrong and that se should apoligize.
ReplyDelete2.i dont know
b.i havent been asked to a group that i was going to be getting along with people...no i would not join a group like that cuz the group is bad so why would i want to join something like that
i felt like that wasnt neccessary at all and that she was justified about that situation.
ReplyDeleteno i think it wadst fair because that group would effect her and her family even though she doesnt know that. she should also think before she joins that group.
posted by edily mendoza
1)i think yes because when she was mad was not thinking at all.
ReplyDelete2)it wouldnt be fair because the group would effect their family.
1. I think she was having problems and was stressed and like that your mom and thats messed up.
ReplyDelete2. Thats not fair because it didnt affect her in anyway and also
1 i think she has a right to be angry at her mom because all the things happen to her. 2 it was the right thing to take herout the group because a black person in a red paper it can make the shcool safer. and i never joined a group.
ReplyDelete1. I think she was justified about what she said to her mother.
ReplyDelete2(a).it was not fair of the people to take her out of the committee because of the class status.
2(b).no I haven't been asked to be in a group that I feel I don't belong to.
on the secound question i think that it wasnt fair to her because they dont know if it was her family there is probly another family that has the last name jiang so why do they have to attack her family because of the last names
ReplyDelete